Myth and the Irish State by John Regan

By John Regan

How can we strategy stricken histories? may still historians try and get well the previous and inform it as they imagined it relatively was once? Or may still they be extra artistic and write histories larger fitted to the desires of the present?

These vexed questions tell old writing on 20th century eire. This quantity of 'problem-articles' and review-essays explores what historian John M. Regan calls 'historical anomalies'. those are pointed out the place inconsistencies and blunders seem within the interpretation of old info. Why does severe proof occasionally cross unseen? How does a historian develop an interpretation of whatever that would be termed 'ethnic detoxing' with no verifiable proof? Why achieve this many Irish historians describe Michael Collins as a 'constitutionalist' or a 'democrat' while the proof argues another way? was once the Irish civil warfare particularly fought among 'democrats' protecting the country, opposed to 'dictators' making an attempt its overthrow?
Did the recent country in short adventure a military-dictatorship below Collins in 1922? Is there anything mistaken with the interpretative strategy hired by way of a few Irish historians?

'Thinking traditionally' isn't approximately studying historical past or accepting the previous because it is gifted to us - it's, Regan argues, approximately constructing the severe abilities to interpret heritage for ourselves.

Show description

Read Online or Download Myth and the Irish State PDF

Similar historical studies books

El bicentenario de la independencia de los países latinoamericanos: Ayer y hoy (Bolsillo nº 87) (Spanish Edition)

Sobre los angeles base de numerosas investigaciones y publicaciones historiográficas, este libro propone un juicio sintético sobre los criterios fundamentales para afrontar las actuales conmemoraciones y celebraciones del bicentenario. En él se recapitulan algunas hipótesis rectoras sobre aquella fase histórica para intentar plantear con claridad el legado que dejó los angeles independencia y las grandes tareas históricas que los pueblos latinoamericanos tienen que asumir en el presente y en el próximo futuro.

An Exemplary Whig: Edward Kent and the Whig Disposition in American Politics and Law

Historians have paid strangely little awareness to state-level political leaders and judges. Edward Kent (1802–77) used to be either. He served 3 phrases as a kingdom legislator, as mayor of Bangor, as governor, and as a pass judgement on of the country best courtroom. He represented Maine within the negotiations that resolved the long-running northeastern border dispute among the U.S. and nice Britain and served for 4 years because the American consul in Rio de Janeiro.

Memory, Subjectivities, and Representation: Approaches to Oral History in Latin America, Portugal, and Spain (Palgrave Studies in Oral History)

This assortment provides various scholarly techniques to oral narratives within the Spanish and Portuguese-speaking worlds. 11 essays, initially written in Spanish, Portuguese, and English, coalesce round significant subject matters that experience lengthy involved oral historians and social scientists: collective stories of conflictive nationwide pasts, subjectivity in re/framing social identities, and visible and performative re/presentations of id and public reminiscence.

Modern Germany in Transatlantic Perspective

Bringing jointly incisive contributions from a global crew of associates and previous scholars, glossy Germany in Transatlantic viewpoint takes inventory of the sector of German historical past as exemplified via the intense scholarly profession of Konrad H. Jarausch. via interesting reflections at the discipline's theoretical, specialist, and methodological dimensions, it explores Jarausch's huge paintings as a instructor and a builder of scholarly associations.

Additional info for Myth and the Irish State

Example text

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.73 of 5 – based on 13 votes